Leave it to me to end the poll then totally forget to post the results.
Peanut Brittle: 9 votes (7 here, 2 boolprop)
Mochaccino: 5 votes (5 here, 0 boolprop)
Candy Cane: 4 votes (4 here, 0 boolprop)
Chai Tea: 3 votes (1 here, 2 boolprop)
Cinnamon: 1 vote
Holly Berry: 1 vote
With no votes for over 24 hours, I figured there was enough of a gap between first and second to call it quits.